Kommentare Abstract
2019/1 Zielgruppen

What can Big Data do for the cultural sector?

Kommentare Abstract

Exploring the characteristics and potential of Big Data for the cultural sector.

«Big Data» is a buzz phrase of the moment, of that there can be no doubt. In the many discussions I had in travelling the UK and Europe discussing the potential of data-driven decision-making in the cultural sector, there is almost unanimous agreement that data can be a powerful asset and that, in many parts of the cultural sphere, it is currently underused.
Whilst the trendiness of the phrase itself will certainly decline, the characteristics of big data are here to stay. It is trite to say that the world we live in includes an unprecedented volume of data, capturing, recording and measuring a greater variety of activity than ever before and coming at us at increasing velocity. Whilst the precise definition of «Big Data» varies depending on the author and the audience, the behaviours and insights to which volume, variety and velocity can give rise are profound. «Before Big Data, our analysis was usually limited to testing a small number of hypotheses that we defined well before even collecting the data. When we let the data speak, we can make connections that we never thought existed.»1

Aggregating data about the behaviour of cultural consumers could provide powerful new arguments both for the provision and allocation of public funding and for the measurement of its impact. But, ideally, this will need to rest on a culture which genuinely sees public money as an investment (rather than subsidy) and which values a two-way, regular and honest exchange of data and information between funder and funded which goes beyond the necessary elements of accountability and governance. Such an approach could have a genuinely revolutionary effect on cultural provision.

How can Big Data help the average cultural sector player?

Firstly, it helps to go where the Big Data already is. What could something like Google Analytics tell you about demand for a new production? How might analysis of the behaviour of a Facebook Group be compared to large-scale segmentation using Facebook’s own ad tools and then compared to the behaviour of the part of «your» audience, which has similar demographic characteristics? These examples uses some element of big data-type approaches to rethink at least one component of traditional decision-making.
And it is the decision-making which is the key. Whether the data is technically defined as «big» is of comparatively little importance in some ways. It is the use of data-driven approaches to drive insight and change behaviour which matters. 
Put simply, almost all cultural organisations already live in a world of greater volume and variety of data - even if they don’t yet harness it. Many are exploring the opportunities and challenges of velocity (for instance through the liveness of Twitter). But very few have an integrated strategic approach and the skills and tools to make the most (or even much sense) of the potential that they are faced with.
One way to think about data-driven decision-making at the current time is to move away from thinking about simply finding definitive relationships of cause and effect between data points (e.g. single transactions in a ticketing system). Even the smallest of «bigger data» sets benefits more from a process of separating the signal from the noise - of letting the data «speak». Many of us have been trained or conditioned to use data to prove our point - and this still has a place - but the confident use of larger data sets can go beyond that.

Even if many cultural organisations have «bigger» data rather than Big Data, the challenge of increasing data-driven decision-making is made up of many layers.
Firstly, many organisations believe their data to be poor quality. This may indeed be the case - but there is no such thing as perfect data. So long as a process of continuous improvement and cleaning is in place and that any obvious problems are ironed out before relying too much on data, it’s undoubtedly better to make a start using existing data rather than waiting for it to be «perfect». If you think your data really is terrible, there’s so much of the stuff about nowadays you might even think about starting again - then using your new dataset to check back against the old stuff to find out what, if anything, might be useful after all.

Think about what you need to measure and then start to measure it

From then on in, the tasks get technical for a little while. Systems such as ticketing software must be developed and improved in many organisations. Integration between websites, databases and ticketing needs to be a priority of the user-centred organisation - which is what everyone should be looking to be able to be. Non-ticketed organisations should look for ways in which they can create opportunities to connect with and capture the data they need that is meaningful. Given the velocity of data, reporting can be more about dashboards and less about print outs, more about visualisations than spreadsheets.
But even where (or when) the technical capability exists, real challenges remain. As Nate Silver explains in his book The Signal and the Noise, there is still lots of room for human judgment, pattern spotting and the wisdom of good decision-making. It’s all very well if we can get the data to speak, but someone needs to be listening and taking action for there to be any positive effect.

This is where analysis comes in. A characteristic of Big Data led decision-making is the freedom with which analysts explore data and make connections, test them, tell stories about them through visualisation. There are analytic tools in many box office systems available for interrogation of web and social media traffic (e.g. via Google Analytics and for social media) and yet, from discussions with suppliers, many remain un- or under-used. It could be that this results from a lack of skills. Bringing data scientists from other, non-cultural fields into the sector could be an important way to explore the needs of cultural organisations and to build capacity. Another culprit could be a lack of demand for data in the director’s office or board room.

Few people in the sector would now argue that data and culture don’t, can’t or even shouldn't mix. In an increasingly quantified world, just to stay on top of the zeitgeist, almost by necessity, involves being aware of data in a way which would have seemed alien less than a decade ago when no one had «followers» and «like» was a verb.
But, more than that, the use of data as an asset inside cultural organisations would accelerate if the stories it was used to tell were better told, more beautiful, playful and startling. Around the world, artists themselves are working with data in amazing and thought-provoking ways and, more mundanely, people are using dashboards to control their social media feeds or weight-loss. Assuming that the foundation of the raw materials is strong enough, the analytics robust and the people in the room willing to listen; data-driven decision-making could and perhaps should be a key element of increasing artistic impact and commercial resilience both for individual organisations and for the sector as a whole. And it could be based on beautifully evidenced stories.

Audiences expect personalitation

How do we use the data - big, bigger or just bog-standard, to generate new ways of looking at old (or novel) questions? That’s where experience, creativity and necessity are a powerful combination. Counting what counts is important and there are new ways of counting things which had previously been beyond the realms of numbers. Looking to new ways, such as sentiment or semantic analysis to measure aspects of artistic impact could also be an important new tool for the cultural sector.
But there’s plenty that can be done today. The measurability of everyday life is growing at an amazing rate, as personal devices such as smartphones and tablets proliferate and as social data, loyalty cards and the rest combine to record aspects of life that were outside the scope of measurement in the quite recent past. Couple this with the developing expectations of audiences for personalisation and the levels of service provided by digital companies such as Amazon, and data is already a key tool in the armoury if used effectively.
This is definitely a marathon not a sprint and the current buzzy popularity of the phrase «Big Data» is helping to get people thinking. That can only be a good thing. After all data-driven decision-making has been around for years and is certainly no fad, it’s just becoming more useful all the time.

Lilley Anthony 2018

Anthony Lilley

Anthony Lilley is CEO of Magic Lantern Productions Ltd, an award-winning interactive media and multiplatform creative house and consultancy and also a non-executive director of media sepcialists Zespa Media. Anthony has worked on world leading brands including Sony Playstation, BBC, London 2012 and Google. He holds the Professorship of Creative Industries at Ulster University, a Visiting Professorship at the UK Centre of Excellence for Media at Bournemouth University and is a previous Professor at the University of Oxford. 

  • 1 Mayer-Schönberger, Viktor; Cukier, Kenneth, Big Data – A Revolution That Will Transform How We Live, Work and Think, Boston, Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, 2013.

Kommentare

*Pflichtfeld

Guest

https://medrxfast.com/# pet meds without vet prescription canada

Guest

https://medrxfast.com/# buy prescription drugs from canada cheap
<a href=https://medrxfast.com/#>best online canadian pharmacy</a> how can i order prescription drugs without a doctor

Guest

pain meds without written prescription <a href=" https://medrxfast.com/# ">buy prescription drugs from canada</a>

Guest

prescription meds without the prescriptions <a href=" https://medrxfast.com/# ">canadian online drugs</a>
https://medrxfast.com/# canadian drugs online
<a href=https://medrxfast.com/#>comfortis without vet prescription</a> buy prescription drugs from india

Guest

<a href=https://medrxfast.com/#>comfortis without vet prescription</a> pet meds without vet prescription canada

Guest

https://medrxfast.com/# prescription drugs online without doctor

Guest

<a href=https://medrxfast.com/#>pet antibiotics without vet prescription</a> ed meds online without doctor prescription

Guest

https://medrxfast.com/# pain meds online without doctor prescription

Guest

prescription drugs online without doctor <a href=" https://medrxfast.com/# ">prescription drugs without doctor approval</a>

Guest

https://medrxfast.com/# amoxicillin without a doctor's prescription
<a href=https://medrxfast.com/#>cheap pet meds without vet prescription</a> ed meds online canada

Guest

https://medrxfast.com/# canadian online drugs

Guest

canadian medications <a href=" https://medrxfast.com/# ">tadalafil without a doctor's prescription</a>
https://medrxfast.com/# best canadian pharmacy online
<a href=https://medrxfast.com/#>prescription drugs online</a> buy prescription drugs online without

Guest

<a href=https://medrxfast.com/#>canadian medications</a> canadian medications

Guest

best male enhancement <a href=" https://drugsbestprice.com/# ">buy canadian drugs</a>

Guest

https://drugsbestprice.com/# solutions for ed

Guest

ed pills that work quickly <a href=" https://drugsbestprice.com/# ">cheap medication</a>

Guest

https://drugsbestprice.com/# best pharmacy online
<a href=https://drugsbestprice.com/#>drugs online</a> mens erections

Guest

https://drugsbestprice.com/# comfortis for dogs without vet prescription

Guest

best male enhancement pills <a href=" https://drugsbestprice.com/# ">pills for ed</a>

Guest

https://drugsbestprice.com/# ed medicine online

Guest

purchase stromectol <a href=" https://stromectolbestprice.com/# ">stromectol buy uk</a>

Guest

egg withdrawal ivermectin <a href=" https://stromectolbestprice.com/# ">buy stromectol 6 mg online</a>
http://stromectolbestprice.com/# equine ivermectin

Guest

treating heartworms with ivermectin and doxycycline <a href=" http://stromectolbestprice.com/# ">where to buy ivermectin for dogs</a>
https://stromectolbestprice.com/# doctors who prescribe ivermectin online
<a href=https://stromectolbestprice.com/#>demodectic mange treatment ivermectin</a> how long does ivermectin last

Guest

<a href=https://stromectolbestprice.com/#>ivermectin tablet 1mg</a> who ivermectin

Guest

https://stromectolbestprice.com/# ivermectin for dogs dosage

Guest

stromectol cheap <a href=" http://stromectolbestprice.com/# ">stromectol 3 mg tablet price</a>

Guest

http://stromectolbestprice.com/# stromectol 3mg
<a href=http://stromectolbestprice.com/#>stromectol price in india</a> cost of stromectol medication

Guest

stromectol tablets <a href=" https://stromectolbestprice.com/# ">stromectol covid 19</a>

Guest

http://stromectolbestprice.com/# stromectol nz

Guest

ivermectin 80 mg <a href=" http://stromectolbestprice.com/# ">ivermectin discovery</a>
https://stromectolbestprice.com/# ivermectin shampoo
<a href=https://stromectolbestprice.com/#>ivermectin pour-on for human lice</a> ivermectin side effects on kidneys

Guest

<a href=https://stromectolbestprice.com/#>ivermectin medication</a> stromectol scabies

Guest

ivermectin 8000 <a href=" http://stromectolbestprice.com/# ">oral ivermectin</a>

Guest

<a href=https://canadiandrugs.best/#>canadian drug prices</a> canada ed drugs

Guest

https://canadiandrugs.best/# meds online without doctor prescription

Guest

canadian online drugs <a href=" https://canadiandrugs.best/# ">pet meds without vet prescription</a>

Guest

<a href=https://erectionpills.shop/#>cures for ed</a> natural ed medications

Guest

https://allpharm.store/# Copegus

Guest

https://erectionpills.shop/# ed pill

Guest

best ed treatment pills <a href=" https://erectionpills.shop/# ">the best ed pill</a>

Guest

https://canadiandrugs.best/# comfortis for dogs without vet prescription

Guest

canadian online drugstore <a href=" https://canadiandrugs.best/# ">dog antibiotics without vet prescription</a>

Guest

https://onlinepharmacy.men/# pill pharmacy

Guest

<a href=https://erectionpills.shop/#>ed treatments</a> treatment for ed

Guest

https://canadiandrugs.best/# buy anti biotics without prescription

Guest

https://erectionpills.shop/# ed pills that really work

Guest

pain meds without written prescription <a href=" https://canadiandrugs.best/# ">canadian drug</a>

Guest

https://canadiandrugs.best/# online canadian drugstore

Guest

<a href=https://canadiandrugs.best/#>buy prescription drugs without doctor</a> prescription meds without the prescriptions

Guest

Diflucan <a href=" https://allpharm.store/# ">Sumycin</a>

Guest

canadian drugs <a href=" https://canadiandrugs.best/# ">canadian pharmacy</a>

Guest

<a href=https://erectionpills.shop/#>compare ed drugs</a> otc ed pills

Guest

https://onlinepharmacy.men/# rate online pharmacies

Guest

https://canadiandrugs.best/# canadian pharmacy

Guest

https://pharmacyizi.com/# prescription drugs online without doctor

Guest

https://pharmacyizi.com/# buy prescription drugs online legally

Guest

<a href=https://pharmacyizi.com/#>natural ed remedies</a> ed for men

Guest

https://pharmacyizi.com/# ed meds online

Guest

https://pharmacyizi.com/# best ed medications

Guest

https://pharmacyizi.com/# medication drugs

Guest

https://pharmacyizi.com/# online ed pills

Guest

https://pharmacyizi.com/# doctors for erectile dysfunction

Guest

ed causes and treatment <a href=" https://pharmacyizi.com/# ">new erectile dysfunction treatment</a>

Guest

https://pharmacyizi.com/# men with ed

Guest

cheap pills online <a href=" https://pharmacyizi.com/# ">viagra without a doctor prescription</a>

Guest

https://pharmacyizi.com/# best ed drug

Guest

<a href=https://pharmacyizi.com/#>google viagra dosage recommendations</a> male ed drugs

Guest

https://pharmacyizi.com/# ed help

Guest

https://pharmacyizi.com/# ed drugs over the counter

Guest

https://pharmacyizi.com/# ed cure

Guest

<a href=https://pharmacyizi.com/#>ed symptoms</a> male dysfunction

Guest

https://pharmacyizi.com/# buy medication online

Guest

https://stromectoltrust.com/# stromectol 12 mg tablets

Guest

order stromectol over the counter <a href=" https://stromectoltrust.com/# ">order stromectol over the counter</a>

Guest

https://stromectoltrust.com/# order stromectol over the counter

Guest

price of ivermectin tablets <a href=" https://stromectoltrust.com/# ">stromectol 12 mg tablets</a>

Guest

stromectol 12 mg tablets <a href=" https://stromectoltrust.com/# ">stromectol 12 mg tablets</a>

Guest

https://stromectoltrust.com/# ivermectin noromectin

Guest

https://stromectoltrust.com/# order stromectol over the counter

Guest

stromectol for humans for sale <a href=" https://stromectoltrust.com/# ">stromectol</a>

Guest

doxycycline without prescription <a href=" https://doxycyclineonline.store/# ">doxycycline otc</a>

Guest

buy ed pills online <a href=" https://drugsonline.store/# ">foods for ed</a>

Guest

best ed drugs <a href=" https://drugsonline.store/# ">cheap medications</a>

Guest

clomid 50mg tablet online <a href=" https://clomidonline.icu/# ">cheap clomid</a>
https://doxycyclineonline.store/# doxycycline pills buy
<a href=https://stromectol.life/#>stromectol</a> stromectol 6 mg tablet

Guest

https://stromectol.life/# stromectol

Guest

generic ivermectin <a href=" https://stromectol.life/# ">stromectol</a>

Guest

<a href=https://clomidonline.icu/#>clomid</a> clomid for sale

Guest

cheap ed pills <a href=" https://edpills.best/# ">best pill for ed</a>

Guest

https://clomidonline.icu/# generic clomid for sale

Guest

generic clomid for sale <a href=" https://clomidonline.icu/# ">cheap clomid</a>

Guest

doxycycline without prescription <a href=" https://doxycyclineonline.store/# ">doxycycline</a>
https://stromectol.life/# generic ivermectin
<a href=https://doxycyclineonline.store/#>doxycycline for sale</a> doxycycline for sale

Guest

<a href=https://stromectol.life/#>ivermectin cream cost</a> stromectol 12 mg tablets

Guest

generic clomid for sale <a href=" https://clomidonline.icu/# ">clomid coupon</a>

Guest

https://doxycyclineonline.store/# doxycycline

Guest

https://clomidonline.icu/# buy clomid

Guest

best over the counter ed pills <a href=" https://drugsonline.store/# ">best ed treatments</a>

Guest

https://clomidonline.icu/# generic clomid for sale

Guest

cheap clomid <a href=" https://clomidonline.icu/# ">cheap clomid</a>
https://edpills.best/# ed pill
<a href=https://drugsonline.store/#>medications for ed</a> ed medicine online

Guest

ivermectin cream cost <a href=" https://stromectol.life/# ">stromectol for sale</a>

Guest

https://erectionpills.best/# best ed treatment

Guest

diflucan price canada <a href=" https://diflucan.icu/# ">diflucan best price</a>

Guest

cipro online no prescription in the usa <a href=" https://cipro.best/# ">buy ciprofloxacin over the counter</a>
https://erectionpills.best/# erectile dysfunction pills
<a href=https://erectionpills.best/#>new ed pills</a> non prescription ed drugs

Guest

neurontin 100 mg caps <a href=" https://gabapentin.icu/# ">neurontin pills</a>

Guest

https://erectionpills.best/# best non prescription ed pills

Guest

neurontin prices generic <a href=" https://gabapentin.icu/# ">neurontin tablets</a>
https://gabapentin.icu/# neurontin cap
<a href=https://diflucan.icu/#>diflucan daily</a> diflucan prescription

Guest

medicine for erectile <a href=" https://erectionpills.best/# ">ed meds</a>

Guest

neurontin 400mg <a href=" https://gabapentin.icu/# ">brand name neurontin</a>
https://gabapentin.icu/# neurontin cream
<a href=https://withoutprescription.store/#>cheap pet meds without vet prescription</a> canadian drug

Guest

п»їed drugs online from canada <a href=" https://withoutprescription.store/# ">canadian medications</a>

Guest

<a href=https://erectionpills.best/#>new ed treatments</a> cheap ed drugs

Guest

https://withoutprescription.store/# prescription drugs online without doctor

Guest

neurontin 2400 mg <a href=" https://gabapentin.icu/# ">neurontin tablets 300mg</a>

Guest

https://withoutprescription.store/# buy prescription drugs online legally

Guest

medication diflucan price <a href=" https://diflucan.icu/# ">diflucan for sale online</a>
https://erectionpills.best/# ed pill
<a href=https://erectionpills.best/#>ed meds online</a> cheapest ed pills

Guest

neurontin price <a href=" https://gabapentin.icu/# ">neurontin cost</a>

Guest

https://erectionpills.best/# best non prescription ed pills

Guest

ciprofloxacin mail online <a href=" https://cipro.best/# ">cipro</a>
https://erectionpills.best/# cheapest ed pills online
<a href=https://withoutprescription.store/#>dog antibiotics without vet prescription</a> ed meds online without prescription or membership

Guest

where to buy diflucan otc <a href=" https://diflucan.icu/# ">diflucan otc uk</a>

Guest

diflucan drug <a href=" https://diflucan.icu/# ">diflucan canada online</a>
https://diflucan.icu/# diflucan pill for sale
<a href=https://cipro.best/#>buy cipro online</a> buy cipro online without prescription

Guest

buy ciprofloxacin <a href=" https://cipro.best/# ">п»їcipro generic</a>
https://withoutprescription.store/# canada ed drugs
<a href=https://gabapentin.icu/#>buy neurontin canada</a> buy neurontin uk

Guest

<a href=https://withoutprescription.store/#>prescription drugs online without</a> pet antibiotics without vet prescription

Guest

https://cipro.best/# buy generic ciprofloxacin

Guest

new ed pills <a href=" https://erectionpills.best/# ">medicine for impotence</a>

Guest

diflucan rx online <a href=" https://diflucan.icu/# ">buy diflucan no prescription</a>
https://withoutprescription.store/# buy canadian drugs
<a href=https://gabapentin.icu/#>buy cheap neurontin</a> neurontin 800 mg pill

Guest

diflucan tablets price <a href=" https://diflucan.icu/# ">diflucan buy</a>

Guest

ciprofloxacin mail online <a href=" https://cipro.best/# ">ciprofloxacin order online</a>
https://diflucan.icu/# price of diflucan in south africa
<a href=https://erectionpills.best/#>medicine for erectile</a> ed pills otc

Guest

https://diflucan.icu/# 3 diflucan pills

Guest

cvs prescription prices without insurance <a href=" https://withoutprescription.store/# ">cat antibiotics without pet prescription</a>

Guest

medicine erectile dysfunction <a href=" https://erectionpills.best/# ">best male enhancement pills</a>
https://erectionpills.best/# top ed pills
<a href=https://erectionpills.best/#>cheapest ed pills online</a> pills for erection

Guest

https://cipro.best/# cipro 500mg best prices

Guest

neurontin prescription medication <a href=" https://gabapentin.icu/# ">neurontin 400 mg capsules</a>
https://diflucan.icu/# diflucan 15 mg
<a href=https://cipro.best/#>cipro for sale</a> buy cipro online

Guest

buy cipro cheap <a href=" https://cipro.best/# ">ciprofloxacin 500mg buy online</a>

Guest

https://buynolvadex.store/# where to buy nolvadex

Guest

tadalafil prescription <a href=" https://buytadalafil.men/# ">buy tadalafil 20mg price canada</a>

Guest

cost of generic lipitor <a href=" https://buylipitor.store/# ">lipitor 20 mg tablet</a>
https://buylasix.icu/# lasix generic
<a href=https://buytadalafil.men/#>tadalafil mexico price</a> tadalafil 5mg tablets price

Guest

tamoxifen buy <a href=" https://buynolvadex.store/# ">nolvadex pct</a>

Guest

https://buylasix.icu/# lasix generic name

Guest

lipitor brand name <a href=" https://buylipitor.store/# ">lipitor generic price canada</a>

Guest

best metformin brand in india <a href=" https://buymetformin.best/# ">metformin over the counter canada</a>
https://buylipitor.store/# lipitor india generic
<a href=https://buytadalafil.men/#>tadalafil prescription</a> tadalafil 20 mg price canada

Guest

<a href=https://buylipitor.store/#>lipitor 10mg price comparison</a> how much is generic lipitor

Guest

https://buylipitor.store/# lipitor simvastatin

Guest

generic tadalafil united states <a href=" https://buytadalafil.men/# ">tadalafil over the counter uk</a>
https://buynolvadex.store/# nolvadex pct
<a href=https://buytadalafil.men/#>tadalafil generic in usa</a> tadalafil 5mg best price

Guest

<a href=https://prednisoneforsale.store/#>prednisone cream over the counter</a> prednisone 200 mg tablets

Guest

buy clomid on line <a href=" https://clomidforsale.life/# ">clomid estrogen</a>

Guest

<a href=https://clomidforsale.life/#>clomid prescription canada</a> clomid 50mg tablet online

Guest

can i buy doxycycline in india <a href=" https://doxycyclineforsale.life/# ">doxycycline generic price</a>
https://prednisoneforsale.store/# prednisone 2.5 mg price
<a href=https://clomidforsale.life/#>online clomid</a> buy clomid canada

Guest

where can i get clomid in south africa <a href=" https://clomidforsale.life/# ">where can i purchase clomid</a>

Guest

zithromax prescription <a href=" https://zithromaxforsale.shop/# ">zithromax coupon</a>

Guest

where can i get amoxicillin 500 mg <a href=" https://amoxilforsale.best/# ">amoxicillin 500 tablet</a>

Guest

https://clomidforsale.life/# buy clomid online mexico

Guest

zithromax 1000 mg online <a href=" https://zithromaxforsale.shop/# ">buy zithromax online fast shipping</a>

Guest

100mg viagra <a href=" https://sildenafilmg.online/# ">viagra over the counter</a>
https://sildenafilmg.online/# over the counter viagra
<a href=https://sildenafilmg.com/#>viagra coupons 75% off</a> over the counter viagra

Guest

best place to buy viagra online <a href=" https://sildenafilmg.shop/# ">viagra price</a>

Guest

buy viagra online canada <a href=" https://sildenafilmg.shop/# ">viagra 100mg price</a>
https://sildenafilmg.com/ viagra from india
<a href=https://sildenafilmg.shop/#>viagra</a> viagra cost per pill

Guest

<a href=https://sildenafilmg.online/#>buy generic 100mg viagra online</a> buy viagra online canada

Guest

https://sildenafilmg.com/ mexican viagra

Guest

mexican viagra <a href=" https://sildenafilmg.online/# ">viagra amazon</a>

Guest

https://sildenafilmg.shop/# viagra 100mg price

Guest

viagra price <a href=" https://sildenafilmg.online/# ">over the counter viagra</a>
https://sildenafilmg.com/ viagra without a doctor prescription
[url=https://sildenafilmg.shop/#]viagra[/url] generic viagra walmart

Guest

viagra 100mg price <a href=" https://sildenafilmg.online/# ">buy generic 100mg viagra online</a>

Guest

<a href=https://sildenafilmg.online/#>cheap viagra online</a> over the counter viagra

Guest

cost of viagra <a href=" https://sildenafilmg.online/# ">cost of viagra</a>
https://sildenafilmg.com/ generic viagra walmart
<a href=https://sildenafilmg.com/#>generic viagra walmart</a> viagra over the counter

Guest

https://sildenafilmg.shop/# viagra 100mg price

Guest

<a href=https://drwithoutdoctorprescription.site/#>pain meds without written prescription</a> how to get prescription drugs without doctor

Guest

purchase viagra cialis paypal <a href=" https://tadalafilusi.com/# ">cialis and alcohol symptoms</a>

Guest

https://drwithoutdoctorprescription.online/# pet antibiotics without vet prescription

Guest

best online canadian pharmacy <a href=" https://drwithoutdoctorprescription.online/# ">canadian drugs online</a>

Guest

<a href=https://drwithoutdoctorprescription.com/#>buy prescription drugs from canada</a> prescription meds without the prescriptions

Guest

buy canadian drugs <a href=" https://drwithoutdoctorprescription.site/# ">prescription drugs without doctor approval</a>

Guest

how cialis works <a href=" https://tadalafilusi.com/# ">cialis pills</a>

Guest

https://drwithoutdoctorprescription.site/ canada ed drugs

Guest

<a href=https://stromectolgf.online/#>ivermectin generic name</a> stromectol usa

Guest

https://stromectolgf.com/# stromectol 6 mg dosage

Guest

ivermectin pill cost <a href=" https://stromectolgf.online/# ">stromectol ivermectin tablets</a>

Guest

cialis super active cheap <a href=" https://tadalafilusi.com/# ">generic version of cialis</a>